My deep and abiding hatred of all forms of transportation with the exception of walking and the French rail system always leads me to have horrible nightmares the evening before travel (later today we drive to Broken Bow, OK to share Thanksgiving with my Dad's Uncle Rupert, who raises fighting roosters and sells them for a good chunk of change to people in Mexico; I'm not kidding, I'll post some pictures when we get back).
Last night's was a doozy. It involved not being able to check in to the Francis Drake hotel in San Fransisco during an American Philosophical Association meeting. The woman at the desk wasn't able to work the keypad because of these grotesque really long fingernails, I mean as long as Howard Hughes' were when he was holed up on a closed off floor of that Vegas hotel during the last phase of his madness (which also involved collecting his own waste in big glass jars that were then set up artfully around the room). She kept having to start over. In the dream this somehow telescoped into thirty minutes, at which point the time for presenting my paper had passed.
All of that would have been fine, but somehow the long fingernail woman knew I'd missed my paper presentation and she kept insisting that my department would not reimburse me now, so I couldn't check in.
I was too polite to point out that it was all because of her fingernails, so I didn't know what to say.
But at that point I saw that David Bowie (David Bowie!) was in the lounge area, and I took a desperate gambit, "Hey, hey, see David Bowie over there. I used to play guitar for him."
She was too cool for this though, "Sir, lots of people have played guitar for David Bowie; that's hardly reason for me to let you check into the Francis Drake."
I was sure that the wonder-working powers of Mr. Bowie would get me through this though. I hailed him like an old friend, confident that he'd recognize me as a humble foot soldier of Rock, and in the ways of all great generals through history, help me out of this bind. George Patton did the same kind of thing for his men. So did Caesar.
And I think I would have gotten the divine intervention, but the Bowie I got was the shell-of-himself-Bowie that surfaced after the release of Aladdin Sane, the very same Bowie whose months long diet of cocaine and milk left him skeletal and insane (he was only later to exit the Los Angeles valley of death by taking bosom buddy Iggy Pop to Berlin). In my nightmare Bowie kept pinching his nose and rubbing his gums, and somehow I knew that he might begin a horrible duet with Cher.
But instead of going sub-par Lawrence Welk on me, Bowie just poked at me with his walking stick and said, "No dice Cogburn." He turned to the desk clerk and told her, "I've never seen this man before in my life."
I was disconsolate, but felt better when David Chalmers began to check in on my right. I was about to hail him when he turned around and punched me in the face really hard. As I lay on the ground, looking up, he said, "I heard that song you wrote, mother******!" before kicking me in the ribs really hard.
I tried to give as good as I got; from the floor I said, "You're not the most important philosopher from Generation X. You're not even from Generation X, look at your damn hippie hair!"
He leaned over and slapped me across the face. It hurt, and if it wasn't a dream I would have wet my pants at that point. Chalmers made a fist, shook it at me, and glowered through what I now realized to be in fact heavy metal hair. I will never make that mistake vis a vis David Chalmers ever, ever again.
"First, unlike me, the hippies had long scraggly bangs that got in their food as they ate. Close inspection reveals my coif to be cropped in front. If you were a better philosopher you would have noticed that. Second, the whole point of Generation X is wearing your hair," and then he started kicking me again and again to emphasize each word, "Any!" Kick! "Way!" Kick! "You!" Kick! "Want!" Kick! Kick! Kick!
I wanted to argue that he was fraudulently wrong. Wearing your hair how you want was the hippie ethos, and all the heavy metal kids like Chalmers had just got that one wrong. Pace Chalmers, "The whole point" of Generation X is being so horribly deformed by overexposure to situation comedies and game shows as a small child that you end up not even suspecting just how awful the Star Wars movies are. How could the man who'd distinguished between the hard and soft problems of consciousness miss that? How could anybody? But I was in too much trauma from Chalmers' cowboy boots to insist on anything.
But things got worse. Through my post Chalmers beating reverie I looked up only to see the two Davids walking away arm and arm, and Bowie was now an amalgam of all of his greatest moments. He was wearing the dress from The Man Who Sold the World/Hunky Dory era. He was in Aladdin Sane Zigster makeup. His teeth were capped beautifully from his post Let's Dance era. And he'd picked David Chalmers over me.
O.K. I should have known better about the hair thing. I'm willing to admit that.
But who could have predicted that David Bowie had such an abiding interest in two-dimensionalism and the extended mind thesis? And so little interest in anything I might have to say about Dummettian anti-realism, the Lucas-Penrose argument, or the metaphysics of video games? My world had collapsed all around me, and there was nothing to do but weep. As they walked away I heard Bowie say to Chalmers, "So what's it going to be tonight old chap? Philosophy or music?"
But then through my veil of tears I saw David Lewis (David Lewis!) checking in. But instead of awe, I tried to score cheap points off of his metaphysical status. "Hey! Hey! He's not even alive!" Given the level to which I'd sunk, perhaps it is better that nobody listened. I grew more disconsolate.
Then my friend David Merli was checking in. This cheered me up, until I saw he had that Aladdin Sane lightning bolt tattooed across his face. Merli was in on it!
Richard Montague stood in line behind Merli, "Hey! Hey! He's dead and his name's not even David!"
"Shut up you little worm! I had it legally changed in Nevada!"
I couldn't win. The Davids had taken over the American Philosophical Association, and they were not to be messed with. If David Chalmers could administer such a horrendous asswhooping, how much worse would it be to tangle with an undead Richard (now David!) Montague.
I slowly drug myself into the cold San Fransisco street, sitting on the pavement with some punk rock kids who'd never even heard of the Dead Kennedys. Inside the Drake everybody talked about philosophy and rocked out while I contemplated life among my new friends under our new David overlords. I would have to get used to the fleas. Yes, that would suck, but the thing was I still had my brain. I still had my brain.